How to choose an e-commerce accountant in Ireland: 10 questions to ask

Richie Lennon

At a glance: A good e-commerce accountant can show you how your Shopify or Amazon sales become your bank payouts, knows when your EU sales cross €10,000, values your stock every month and tells you your margin after ads and fees. Ask the ten questions below before you hire anyone. If they can’t answer three of them clearly, keep looking.

Most accountants can file a VAT return for an online store. Far fewer can tell you what the store actually made last month. The difference only shows up after you’ve hired them, so test it before.

These are the ten questions we’d ask if we were hiring an accountant for an Irish online business. Each one has what a good answer sounds like, and the answer that should worry you.

1. “Do you record my sales from Shopify, or from the bank?”

Good answer: From Shopify’s own reports. Gross sales, VAT, discounts, shipping and refunds are posted separately, fees go in as costs, and a clearing account brings each payout back to zero.

Red flag: “We use the bank feed.” Payouts are sales after fees and refunds. Booked as revenue, they understate your turnover and hide your costs. See accounting for Shopify stores in Ireland.

2. “Who watches the €10,000 EU threshold?”

Good answer: They track your consumer sales to other EU countries and Northern Ireland during the year, and tell you before you cross €10,000, not after.

Red flag: They check at year end. By then you’ve been charging Irish VAT on sales that should have carried the customer’s rate. See VAT OSS for Irish e-commerce.

3. “When do I need to register for Irish VAT?”

Good answer: Once goods sales pass €85,000 a year, or earlier if you buy services from abroad or sell into the EU. They’ll also tell you whether registering early makes sense for your margins.

Red flag: A threshold with no follow-up questions about where you sell and who you buy from. See the VAT threshold guide.

4. “What happens with UK orders?”

Good answer: Consumer orders of £135 or less mean UK VAT registration and UK returns, because Shopify isn’t a marketplace. Above £135, import VAT and duty apply at the border.

Red flag: “Brexit doesn’t affect you if you’re Irish.”

5. “How will you value my stock?”

Good answer: Monthly, from your stock records, including freight in, duty and packaging, so the margin you see is real while you can still act on it.

Red flag: A stock figure once a year, at year end. You’ll find out your margin was wrong twelve months too late. See inventory accounting for e-commerce.

6. “What margin report do I get, and after which costs?”

Good answer: Margin after product cost, fulfilment, payment fees and advertising, every month.

Red flag: A turnover and ROAS conversation. “All it proves is that spending more on marketing increases sales. It has no reference to the bottom line. A client can improve ROAS while going broke.”

7. “How do you treat gift cards and refunds?”

Good answer: Gift cards usable across products at different VAT rates are a liability until they’re redeemed, with VAT due at redemption. Refunds reduce both sales and VAT.

Red flag: Gift card sales booked as revenue on the day they’re sold.

8. “What do you need from me each month, and by when?”

Good answer: A short, specific list: platform access, supplier invoices, stock counts. A date for each.

Red flag: “Send us everything at year end.” “Compliance is the only thing you can offer someone you speak to once a year.”

9. “Who is my contact, and how fast do you reply?”

Good answer: One named person who knows your store, and a response time they’ll commit to.

Red flag: A shared inbox and “we’ll get back to you”.

10. “What does it cost, and what’s included?”

Good answer: A fixed monthly fee, with the work it covers written down: bookkeeping, VAT, payroll, monthly reporting, year end.

Red flag: An hourly rate with no estimate. You’ll be reluctant to ask questions, which is exactly when you need to.

The checklist

QuestionPass if they say
Sales sourceFrom Shopify reports, with a clearing account
EU thresholdTracked during the year
Irish VAT€85,000 for goods, plus earlier triggers
UK ordersUK VAT on orders of £135 or less
StockValued monthly, landed cost
MarginAfter ads, fees and fulfilment
Gift cardsLiability until redeemed
Your inputsSpecific list and dates
ContactNamed person, committed reply time
FeeFixed, with scope in writing

When it’s time to switch

If your current accountant fails three or more of these, the work you need isn’t being done. “You can’t flag the thing coming in March if you’re looking at last year the following January.” For an online store, the thing coming in March is usually the €10,000 EU threshold, a VAT rate set wrong on a product line, or a clearing account that stopped clearing in the autumn.

You don’t need to wait for year end to move. Here’s how changing accountant works in Ireland.

How Around Finance answers these

We look after Irish e-commerce businesses on Xero for a fixed monthly fee. Shopify sales are reconciled through a clearing account every month, EU sales are tracked against the €10,000 threshold, and you get a margin report after ads and fees. Every client has a named client manager who replies within 24 hours. See our e-commerce accounting service.

Book a Finance Fit Call

FAQs

What’s the difference between an accountant and an e-commerce accountant?

Experience with platform payouts, stock and cross-border VAT. Any accountant can have it. Test it with the questions above rather than trusting the label.

Do I need a separate VAT registration for Amazon, Shopify and TikTok?

The platform doesn’t decide it. Where your stock is held, where your customers are and whether a marketplace collects the VAT do. Map your sales routes first.

When should an online business start using an accountant?

Before you register a company or for VAT, so the setup is right from the first sale. Fixing a year of payouts booked as sales costs more than getting it right on day one.

What should an e-commerce accountant cost in Ireland?

It depends on your channels, transaction volume and VAT countries. Ask for a fixed monthly fee with the scope in writing. See what accountants cost in Ireland.

Can my accountant work with A2X or Link My Books?

They should. A summarising app posts daily or per-payout totals into Xero, so your accounts aren’t buried in individual orders. The accountant still needs to check the clearing account reconciles.

Share this on:

Outgrown your accountant? See if we’re a fit.

Latest Blogs

Read up on some of our latest business news and useful information.

Scroll to Top

Book a Finance Fit Call

Open the booking calendar in a new tab