Ecommerce pricing in Ireland: set prices from margin, not from competitors

Richie Lennon

Most Irish online stores set prices by looking at competitors and rounding to a number that feels right. Then they find out at year end that a best-selling product barely made money once VAT, fees, delivery, returns and ads came out of it.

At a glance: Price an ecommerce product from the margin you need, not from what competitors charge. Start with the price excluding VAT, since Irish consumer prices usually include 23% VAT that is not yours. Then subtract product cost, payment and platform fees, packaging, delivery you absorb, returns and the advertising cost of winning the order. What is left is contribution per order. If that number does not cover overheads at realistic volumes, the price, the cost base or the product needs to change.

A worked example

The figures below are illustrative, not a client case. They show how quickly a healthy-looking gross margin shrinks.

Per orderAmount
Price paid by customer, including 23% VAT€49.99
Price excluding VAT€40.64
Product cost€14.00
Gross profit€26.64 (66%)
Payment and platform fees€1.60
Packaging and absorbed delivery€6.50
Returns allowance€2.00
Advertising cost per order€12.00
Contribution per order€4.54 (11%)

A 66% gross margin became an 11% contribution margin. At €4.54 an order, the business needs about 2,200 orders to cover €10,000 of monthly overheads. That is the number the price has to be judged against.

VAT is not part of your price

Irish consumers see prices including VAT. At the standard rate of 23%, about 18.7% of every VAT-inclusive euro belongs to Revenue. Some products carry lower rates, and selling into other EU countries can mean charging their VAT rates instead. A price rise of €2 on the shelf is roughly €1.63 to you at 23%.

Ecommerce pricing terminology

Pricing conversations go wrong when people use the same word for different numbers. These are the five that matter.

TermWhat it meansExample
Variable costsCosts that rise with every order: product, packaging, delivery, fees, returns, advertising€36.10 per order in the example above
Fixed costsOverheads that do not change with each order: salaries, software, rent, accountancy€10,000 a month
MarkupProfit as a percentage of costCost €10, price €15 ex VAT: markup 50%
Gross marginProfit after product cost as a percentage of the price ex VATCost €10, price €15 ex VAT: margin 33%
Contribution marginWhat is left per order after every variable cost, available to pay overheads€4.54, or 11%, in the example above

The common mistake is confusing markup with margin. A 50% markup is a 33% margin. Price a product to a “50% margin” by adding 50% to cost and you have priced it to a third less profit than you intended. We go through the arithmetic in margin versus markup.

How to price products for an online store

This is the method we would use for a new product or a repricing exercise. It works from the bottom up, so the market check at the end is a check, not the starting point.

  1. Landed cost per unit. Product cost plus inbound freight, duty and any customs charges.
  2. Per-order costs. Payment and platform fees, packaging, delivery you absorb, and an allowance for returns based on your real return rate.
  3. Advertising cost per order. What it costs, on average, to win the order. For most direct-to-consumer stores this is the largest single number.
  4. Required contribution. Monthly overheads divided by the orders you can realistically expect. This is what each order has to leave behind.
  5. Add VAT and check the market. Add VAT at the rate that applies, round to a sensible price point, and only then compare with competitors.

Using the example product: landed cost €14.00, per-order costs €10.10, advertising €12.00, and a required contribution of €8.00 gives a price of €44.10 excluding VAT, or €54.24 including 23% VAT. The store was charging €49.99. Either the price goes up, the advertising cost comes down, or the business accepts that this product does not carry its share of overheads.

Ecommerce pricing strategies

Every pricing strategy below is a way of choosing where the price sits. None of them changes the cost stack underneath, so each one should be tested against contribution per order.

Cost-plus pricing

Start with cost and add a fixed markup. A product costing €10 with a 50% markup sells for €15 before VAT. It is simple, and every sale makes a gross profit. Its weakness in ecommerce is that it usually starts from product cost alone, so delivery, fees and advertising are left out, and it ignores what customers will actually pay. Cost-plus works best when it is cost-plus on the full variable cost stack, not on the product alone.

Value-based pricing

Price on what the customer believes the product is worth, not on what it cost you. A brand with a strong reputation can charge well above a generic equivalent with the same cost. Value pricing produces the best margins in ecommerce, but it has to be earned through brand, reviews, product quality and service, and it takes time and money to build. For an Irish store competing against marketplaces, value pricing is usually the only way to escape a price war.

Competitor-based pricing

Set the price by reference to competitors: match, undercut or sit deliberately above them. It is the most common approach and the most dangerous, because you are borrowing someone else’s cost base and assuming it matches yours. A competitor with cheaper sourcing, lower advertising costs or a loss-making growth plan is not a safe benchmark. Track competitor prices, but decide against your own contribution numbers.

Psychological pricing

Charm prices such as €49.99 rather than €50, anchor prices next to a premium option, and limited-time offers all fall here. They work, within limits. Online shoppers can compare prices in seconds, so a “sale” price that matches what everyone else charges anyway damages trust. In Ireland, the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission requires any announced price reduction to show the prior price, which is the lowest price charged in at least the 30 days before the reduction.

Dynamic pricing

Change prices in response to demand, stock levels, competitor moves or input costs. Large retailers do this automatically; most Irish stores do it by hand around peak periods, slow-moving stock and supplier price changes. It protects margin when costs rise, but it needs good data and discipline. Frequent changes confuse customers, and every reduction has to respect the prior-price rule.

Bundle pricing

Sell two or more products together at a combined price. Bundles work in ecommerce because they spread the per-order costs, delivery and advertising above all, across more products. Take two of the example product sold as a bundle at 10% off:

Per orderTwo separate ordersOne bundle order
Price excluding VAT€81.28€73.15
Product cost€28.00€28.00
Fees€3.20€2.88
Packaging and delivery€13.00€6.50
Returns allowance€4.00€4.00
Advertising€24.00€12.00
Contribution€9.08€19.77

The bundle gives away €8.13 of price and more than doubles contribution, because it saves one delivery and one advertising cost. The risk is that customers learn to wait for bundles and stop buying single items at full price.

The levers that actually move contribution

  • Advertising cost per order: usually the biggest variable and the one most often ignored in pricing. Return on ad spend is not profit; it is revenue, including VAT, divided by spend.
  • Free delivery thresholds: set them so the average order clears the cost of delivery, not so they match a competitor.
  • Bundles: two items in one parcel share one delivery cost and one advertising cost.
  • Returns: a product category with high returns needs a higher price or a tighter policy.
  • Product cost: supplier terms and minimum order quantities, renegotiated as volume grows.

What a discount really costs

A 20% discount on the example product takes €8.13 off the price excluding VAT. Contribution was €4.54. Every discounted order now loses money unless the discount brings a customer who buys again at full price. That is not a reason never to discount. It is a reason to know the number before the sale goes live.

Discounts also hide in the accounts. A coupon code shows up as a discount line. A site-wide Black Friday price cut has no code, so its cost never appears anywhere: it just shows as lower sales. Unless someone works out what the same orders would have brought in at full price, nobody can say what the sale actually cost.

If your accountant only reports gross margin, you are pricing blind. Gross margin hides every cost that grows with each order, which is most of the costs in ecommerce.

Retail versus ecommerce pricing

A shop on a high street prices against the shop down the road. An online store prices against every store in the search results, plus Amazon. In a physical shop, delivery and advertising do not sit inside every sale; online, they usually do. That is why the same product can make a healthy profit in a shop and lose money online at the same price. Retail pricing habits, especially keystone markups of 100% on cost, often do not survive the move to ecommerce.

What your monthly numbers should show

Monthly accounts for an online store should show contribution by product line or channel, not just total sales and gross profit. That requires fees, delivery and advertising to be coded consistently in the books, which is a bookkeeping discipline before it is a pricing one.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between markup and margin?

Markup is profit as a percentage of cost. Margin is profit as a percentage of price. A product costing €10 and selling for €15 before VAT has a 50% markup and a 33% margin.

What is a good gross margin for an ecommerce business?

It depends on the category and the advertising model, but below 50% gross margin an ecommerce business struggles to survive once delivery, fees and advertising are paid. The better test is contribution per order after every variable cost.

How often should I review my prices?

At least once a year, and whenever a supplier price, delivery rate, platform fee or advertising cost changes materially. Review by product line, not just across the store.

How do I set a free delivery threshold?

Set it so that an order at the threshold still covers the delivery cost and leaves a contribution. A threshold just above your average order value nudges customers to add an item; one far above it is ignored.

Do I have to show the old price when I run a sale?

Yes. In Ireland, a price reduction announcement must show the prior price, which is the lowest price charged in at least the 30 days before the reduction.

Should my prices include VAT?

Prices shown to consumers in Ireland must include VAT. Your pricing calculation should always start from the price excluding VAT, because that is what the business keeps.

Getting the numbers right

Around Finance works with Irish ecommerce businesses on monthly accounts, VAT across EU markets and reporting that shows contribution per order. Book a Finance Fit Call and we will show you how we would set up your reporting.

Related reading: accounting for ecommerce and retail, margin versus markup and ecommerce VAT rules.

Sources

Share this on:

Outgrown your accountant? See if we’re a fit.

Latest Blogs

Read up on some of our latest business news and useful information.

Scroll to Top

Book a Finance Fit Call

Open the booking calendar in a new tab